A European medical device manufacturer came to us with a membrane switch overlay that was cracking around the edges. The device was a bedside patient monitor, and the nurses disinfected the panel with 70 percent isopropyl alcohol after every patient. The buyer had specified an acrylic overlay because it looked glossy and premium. Within six months, fine cracks had spread from the corners of the cutouts, and the overlay was lifting at the edges. The buyer assumed all plastic overlays behaved the same. They do not: acrylic is brittle under repeated chemical exposure, and it cracks where the alcohol seeps into the cutout edges.
We swapped the overlay to a polyester (PET) film, which survives repeated alcohol wipes without cracking. The next year had zero overlay failures. That project is the subject of this guide. When you design a membrane switch, the overlay material is the single most visible and most abused part of the assembly, and the choice between PET, polycarbonate and acrylic determines whether the panel survives the product life.
This guide compares the three overlay films on the parameters that matter in production, maps each to the application it fits, and lists the mistakes buyers make when they specify an overlay based on gloss rather than chemical and abrasion resistance.
How each overlay works
Polyester (PET) is the workhorse overlay film. It is 0.175 to 0.25mm thick, tough, abrasion-resistant, and survives repeated alcohol, disinfectant and oil exposure. It is the standard overlay for industrial, medical and outdoor membrane switches. It is slightly less glossy than acrylic, but it is the most durable of the three.
Polycarbonate (PC) is clearer and glossier than PET, and it thermoforms well into curved or raised-key shapes. It is used where the overlay must wrap around a curved housing or form raised keys. It is less abrasion-resistant than PET and is attacked by some solvents, but it handles mild chemicals and indoor use well.
Acrylic (PMMA) is the glossiest and clearest of the three, and it is the cheapest. It is used for consumer electronics overlays that live indoors and see no harsh chemicals. It is brittle, cracks under repeated solvent exposure, and scratches easily. It is the least durable of the three.

The overlay is the top film the user touches; its material determines chemical, abrasion and UV resistance.
PET vs PC vs Acrylic overlay: comparison table
| Parameter | PET overlay | PC overlay | Acrylic overlay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thickness | 0.175-0.25mm | 0.25-0.5mm | 0.25-1.0mm |
| Abrasion resistance | Excellent | Good | Poor, scratches |
| Alcohol / disinfectant | Excellent | Good | Poor, cracks |
| UV / outdoor | Good | Fair, yellows | Poor, yellows |
| Thermoformable | Limited | Yes | Yes |
| Gloss | Satin | Glossy | Glossiest |
| Relative cost | Moderate | Higher | Lowest |
| Best fit | Medical, industrial, outdoor | Curved, raised keys | Indoor consumer |
Why the material changes the product
The PET overlay is the default for any product that sees chemicals, abrasion or outdoor sun. It is not the glossiest, but it survives the environment the product lives in. This is the material that fixed our medical monitor customer's cracking-overlay problem.
The PC overlay trades some chemical resistance for thermoformability. When the membrane switch must wrap around a curved housing or form raised keys, PC is the film that bends to the shape. It is used in automotive interior panels, curved instrument clusters and raised-key industrial switches. It is not the choice for a panel wiped down with harsh solvents every hour.
The acrylic overlay is the cheapest and glossiest, and it belongs on consumer electronics that live indoors and see no harsh chemicals. A TV front panel, a home appliance fascia or a low-wear control cover uses acrylic. It scratches and cracks under abuse, so it is the wrong choice for a medical or industrial panel.

The overlay sits over the metal domes; the film material must survive the chemicals and abrasion the panel sees.
Which overlay for which application
Medical panels, industrial controls, outdoor equipment - PET. A bedside monitor, a factory control panel or an outdoor instrument that sees alcohol wipes, oil or sun needs a PET overlay. PET survives the chemicals and the abrasion, and it does not yellow in UV. This is the default for any washdown or harsh-environment panel.
Curved housings, raised keys, automotive interiors - PC. A curved car dashboard, a raised-key remote or a contoured industrial panel that must wrap around a housing uses PC. PC thermoforms to the shape, and it handles mild indoor chemicals. It is not the choice for a hospital panel wiped with disinfectant every hour.
Indoor consumer fascia, low-wear covers - acrylic. A TV front, a home appliance fascia or a low-wear control cover that lives indoors uses acrylic. It is the glossiest and cheapest, and it survives gentle indoor use. It is the wrong choice for anything wiped with alcohol or exposed to sun.
Pair with the right circuit under the overlay. The overlay sits over the circuit, which can be a rigid PCB or a flexible printed circuit. The dome sheet array aligns the metal domes under the overlay, and the spacer layers provide the snap gap. We supply the overlay, the circuit and the dome as one program so the overlay material and the circuit are coordinated.
Selection checklist
1. Chemical exposure. If the panel is wiped with alcohol, disinfectant or oil, PET. If it sees only dry indoor use, acrylic. This single question rules out one option.
2. Outdoor UV. If the panel sits in sun, PET. PC and acrylic yellow under UV. PET resists yellowing for years outdoors.
3. Forming. If the overlay must wrap a curve or form raised keys, PC. PET is hard to thermoform; acrylic forms but is brittle.
4. Abrasion. If the panel is touched all day by gloved hands or tools, PET. Acrylic scratches under gloves.
5. Cost. Acrylic is the cheapest, PET is moderate, PC is higher. Specify the material that survives the environment, not the cheapest film that looks good in a sample.
Common selection mistakes
The first mistake is choosing acrylic for a medical or industrial panel. The bedside monitor customer's cracked overlay started exactly this way. Acrylic looks glossy in the sample book, but it cracks under repeated alcohol exposure. For any wiped-down panel, PET.
The second mistake is specifying PC for an outdoor panel. PC yellows under UV, and it is attacked by some solvents. For outdoor panels, PET.
The third mistake is choosing PET when the overlay must thermoform. PET is stiff and does not wrap a curve well. For a contoured housing, PC.
The fourth mistake is ignoring the hard coat. Even a PET overlay benefits from a hard coat for high-abrasion environments. Specify a hard-coated PET overlay for a panel touched all day by gloves.
What we supply and test
At Shanyo we produce membrane switch overlays in PET, PC and acrylic, with screen-printed legends, embossed keys and hard coats. Overlays are tested for abrasion with a Taber tester, for chemical resistance with repeated alcohol wipes, and for UV exposure for outdoor parts. We supply the test report with the order. Prototype overlays ship within 48 hours from a drawing.
Shanyo manufactures custom OEM and wholesale membrane switches for medical, industrial, automotive and consumer products, with IATF 16949 and ISO 13485 quality systems covering automotive and medical programs. Send us your chemical exposure, UV condition and forming requirement, and our engineering team will recommend PET, PC or acrylic and quote factory pricing. Contact Shanyo for a sample overlay in your material and a comparison of the three films for your product.
Cost trade-off, stated plainly
An acrylic overlay is the cheapest because the film is low-cost and screen printing on acrylic is straightforward. A PET overlay adds a small per-piece increase because the film is more expensive and the ink adhesion is a more controlled process. A PC overlay is the most expensive because the film costs more and thermoforming adds a molding step. On a five-button medical panel, the gap between acrylic and PET is a small fraction of the finished device cost.
The mistake buyers make is comparing the off-the-shelf acrylic sample to the PET landed cost and choosing acrylic everywhere. The correct comparison is the cost of a field failure: a cracked overlay on a bedside monitor means the panel must be replaced under warranty, and the hospital loses confidence in the device. One avoided warranty return pays for PET on thousands of panels. For an indoor TV fascia that never sees alcohol, acrylic is the right economic choice.
There is also a lead-time consideration. Flat PET and acrylic overlays are produced in a standard screen-print flow, typically three to five days for prototypes. Thermoformed PC overlays add a molding step, and prototypes take seven to ten days. For a project with a tight schedule, start with a flat PET or acrylic overlay, then move to thermoformed PC once the contour requirement is locked.
What we ask for before recommending a material
To recommend PET, PC or acrylic, we need five inputs: the chemicals the panel is wiped with, whether it sees outdoor UV, whether the overlay must wrap a curve, the daily touch frequency and the annual volume. With those numbers we can rule out the wrong material immediately and recommend the film that fits. Missing the chemical-exposure input is the most common reason a first overlay comes back with cracking or fading, because the buyer specified an acrylic overlay for a hospital panel without telling us.
Abrasion and field reliability
The overlay material does not change the dome feel, but it changes how the panel looks and works over years. A PET overlay holds its legends and its surface for the product life, because the film resists abrasion and chemicals. An acrylic overlay starts glossy, scratches under gloves, and cracks under repeated wipes. For a product expected to run for years in a medical or industrial environment, the PET overlay is the more reliable choice even if the acrylic sample looks glossier in the showroom.
Hard coat, embossing and legend details
Beyond the film, the overlay benefits from a hard coat for high-abrasion environments, embossed keys where the operator must feel the key without looking, and screen-printed or laser-etched legends. We apply a UV-hard coat to PET overlays that see gloved hands, emboss the keys by thermoforming a dome over each switch, and print legends beneath the top coat so they cannot wear off. The result is an overlay the buyer drops onto the circuit, with no separate hard coat or legend to apply on the production line.
We also run Taber abrasion and chemical wipe testing on the overlay as part of the approval, so the buyer sees the legends survive a simulated hospital year before tooling is locked. For a sample, we ship a flat PET overlay on a demo panel so the customer can feel the surface and wipe it with the actual disinfectant used in the field.
Where each film is the wrong choice
To make the decision concrete: do not specify acrylic on a panel that is wiped with alcohol every shift. Do not specify PC on a panel that sits in sun, because it yellows. Do not specify flat PET on a housing that must wrap a curve, because it will not form. And do not specify an uncoated PET overlay on a panel that sees daily gloved use, because the surface wears. These four rules cover the majority of overlay selection mistakes we see returned from the field.
For buyers who need a side-by-side feel, we ship a sample set: a PET, a PC and an acrylic overlay with the same legends. The customer can feel the abrasion, wipe each with the actual disinfectant, and decide which film survives the real environment before tooling. This sample set is the fastest way to avoid a wrong-material return six months into production.
We ship the sample set free of charge for qualified buyers who have a defined program.
- John Smith, Senior Application Engineer, Shanyo Precision Electronics, Qingdao

